A court decision is a legal ruling made by a judge on a case based on the facts and law. A court decision usually consists of a “syllabus” (the section that lists the cases in the case) and one or more opinions. The opinion contains the text of the decision and the reasoning behind it. The court’s opinion is what actually makes the law, and it is not to be confused with the case summary. The case summary is a summary of the facts in the case and explains the legal issues the court was facing. The opinion starts with a history of the case and then goes through the relevant laws and previous court decisions (called precedent) to make its ruling.
A majority of the justices may agree on the outcome of the case, and that becomes known as the majority opinion. Justices who do not agree with the outcome or the majority’s reasoning might write a concurring opinion. A dissenting opinion explains why the justice disagrees with the majority and provides alternative reasons for reaching the same result. Dissents are not as influential as the majority and plurality opinions, but they are still important and provide a foundation for future decisions on similar questions of law.
The Supreme Court has a number of different kinds of rulings that influence everything from student free speech to the way evidence is used in court and the rights of law enforcement officers. The decisions and the reasoning behind them can be complicated. But keeping up with the rulings helps you better understand your rights. And when you need help understanding your rights, turning to a lawyer can make all the difference.
About the Author
